I was a woman on a mission, on the hunt for a brown / bronze shade eye-liner that actually STAYS put in the water-line!!
MAC's Teddy Eye Kohl
Eye of Horus Goddess Pencil - Bronze Amulet
I love this eye pencil for a more softer subtle look, great for a day time. Looks really pretty and has a smudger on the end so you could also use all over the eye lid blended in. A beautiful shade of bronzey-brown, and lovely and creamy to apply but also stays put, which is what you want it to do.
Just wanted to add this one in as a sort of fail and here's why....
So there you have it my brown eye-liners for when a black is a bit too.. well black!